Episode 8

Perspectives From a Lived Life of Overcoming Physical Challenges

Ricardo Rodriguez, independent Accessibility Consultant

Ricardo Rodriguez talks about the challenges of growing up with extreme visual, mobility and cognitive challenges. He describes how a support system helped him adjust to those challenges and made it possible to become a professional accessibility practitioner. 

Mentioned in this episode:

Info about Accessibility at Blink

Transcript
Speaker:

(upbeat music)

Speaker:

- Hello, this is Digital Accessibility,

Speaker:

the People Behind the Progress.

Speaker:

I'm Joe Welinske, the creator and host of this series,

Speaker:

and as an accessibility professional myself,

Speaker:

I find it very interesting as to how others

Speaker:

have found their way into this profession.

Speaker:

So let's meet one of those people right now,

Speaker:

and hear about their journey.

Speaker:

All right, well,

Speaker:

it's time to get started with our next episode

Speaker:

as we meet practitioners

Speaker:

working in the Accessibility area,

Speaker:

and today I'm talking with Ricardo Rodriguez.

Speaker:

Hello Ricardo.

Speaker:

- Hello.

Speaker:

- Hey, it's good to be having this conversation with you.

Speaker:

I'm talking from my home office in Vashon Island,

Speaker:

near Seattle.

Speaker:

Where are you talking to us from?

Speaker:

- Beautiful San Diego, California.

Speaker:

- Well, it's like good to be able to work with you again.

Speaker:

We've worked together in project activities at Blink.

Speaker:

You've also attended the Convey UX conference in Seattle,

Speaker:

and helped out with that,

Speaker:

so I'm happy to have you as part of this activity.

Speaker:

- I'm always happy to help.

Speaker:

- Well, just to kinda recap some of the things

Speaker:

that we've been involved with together,

Speaker:

so there have been some projects that,

Speaker:

that we've had including our work with NASA,

Speaker:

where you've helped out by providing feedback

Speaker:

in some of the things that we are doing in research design

Speaker:

based on your own familiarity with accessibility.

Speaker:

Do you wanna talk a little bit about that kind of work

Speaker:

and how you approach it

Speaker:

in your work as a freelance accessibility consultant?

Speaker:

- Sure, I'd be happy to.

Speaker:

So, for me, the main project is always

Speaker:

trying to figure out what are the needs

Speaker:

that the project is trying to accomplish,

Speaker:

and what are areas that need to be improved upon

Speaker:

when it comes to accessibility?

Speaker:

'Cause one of the things that I've always noticed myself,

Speaker:

whether it's in projects,

Speaker:

or just learning about things,

Speaker:

is that when things are designed,

Speaker:

or projects are designed,

Speaker:

they're not always designed with accessibility in mind.

Speaker:

And that's not really the issue

Speaker:

of the designers or developers,

Speaker:

it's mainly that they don't have the experience

Speaker:

in that field.

Speaker:

So a lot of things that are issues

Speaker:

don't really register right away.

Speaker:

So looking at it from the perspective of someone

Speaker:

who has specific challenges or specific needs,

Speaker:

you're able to see what are some areas of improvement

Speaker:

that other parties may not be able to,

Speaker:

and you can help them on improving those areas.

Speaker:

- Yeah.

Speaker:

And your work's been really helpful

Speaker:

and as some one that had physical challenges,

Speaker:

that gives us remarkably useful insights into the,

Speaker:

as we design and build out new products.

Speaker:

Maybe we could kind of go back in time,

Speaker:

and you could share with us a little bit

Speaker:

about your story of how you've gotten to this point.

Speaker:

- Sure.

Speaker:

So, for me, I was always a bit of a challenge.

Speaker:

I grew up in the late 90's,

Speaker:

limited access to the internet

Speaker:

until the early 2000s,

Speaker:

so it wasn't easy finding resources

Speaker:

to be able to get help for certain challenges

Speaker:

that you may have compared to,

Speaker:

compared to the ease of access we have now.

Speaker:

So for me it was always a challenge

Speaker:

finding the resources to do well in school

Speaker:

with my mobility impairments

Speaker:

or my vision or my motor skills,

Speaker:

especially my cognitive challenges

Speaker:

were always difficult to find resources,

Speaker:

'cause you weren't as connected back then

Speaker:

as you are now.

Speaker:

So for me it always strove to instill a need

Speaker:

of what are the resources that I can get locally?

Speaker:

What can I find that's gonna be able

Speaker:

to make this easy for me as opposed to struggle

Speaker:

because I don't have access to the resources,

Speaker:

or the knowledge on where to go.

Speaker:

Nowadays it's a lot more complex

Speaker:

just because of the fact that you have

Speaker:

a lot of products that are being developed,

Speaker:

but without the understanding of certain challenges, right?

Speaker:

But there is still a move to be able to learn

Speaker:

what are the gaps that a product is needing,

Speaker:

and who can we reach out to

Speaker:

to kind of fill in those gaps?

Speaker:

And doing that sort of work has always

Speaker:

been something that I've always enjoyed,

Speaker:

just because it helps create an awareness

Speaker:

of what the issue is,

Speaker:

and it makes things more inclusive.

Speaker:

- Well, I, working you with you today,

Speaker:

it's almost hard for me to understand

Speaker:

how you were able to overcome so much

Speaker:

because you really had those multiple challenges

Speaker:

that you had to deal with,

Speaker:

and you mentioned them with the visual impairment,

Speaker:

also mobility,

Speaker:

and then some cognitive challenges.

Speaker:

Maybe you could talk a little bit more about that

Speaker:

and what types of things you worked through in your own life

Speaker:

to be able to adjust to it,

Speaker:

and get to where you are today?

Speaker:

- Sure.

Speaker:

So, as I mentioned,

Speaker:

I was born in the late 90's,

Speaker:

with limited access to resources.

Speaker:

Basically I was born essentially five months premature,

Speaker:

so I didn't develop as well as one normally does.

Speaker:

So the diagnosis at the time was

Speaker:

I had cereal palsy, ADHD, limited vision,

Speaker:

and I was also slightly retarded,

Speaker:

as the term used to be called.

Speaker:

So because of that I was always severely delayed.

Speaker:

I couldn't do things that a normal three year old do, right?

Speaker:

I wasn't cognitive of what was happening around me

Speaker:

because of my severe delays.

Speaker:

I was just aware that I was looking at things,

Speaker:

but I didn't actively register

Speaker:

what it was that I was looking at,

Speaker:

or what it was that was happening to me.

Speaker:

Once I got older, I was still 11 years old

Speaker:

with the mentality of a three year old.

Speaker:

So my brain hadn't caught up yet with the fact that

Speaker:

hey, I'm 11 now,

Speaker:

I can now register what's happening.

Speaker:

It wasn't until I started getting some support

Speaker:

that slowly but surely,

Speaker:

as technology and access to resources

Speaker:

and knowledge started coming out,

Speaker:

I started to develop little by little

Speaker:

with a good support system,

Speaker:

I started to be able to, for example,

Speaker:

learn how to read,

Speaker:

learn how to pronunciate my letters,

Speaker:

which you do at a very early age.

Speaker:

By the time you're four

Speaker:

most children are already able to speak,

Speaker:

and have somewhat understandable conversations.

Speaker:

And here I was starting to just barely do my ABCs.

Speaker:

So it was a lot of work

Speaker:

to be able to kind of get to the point of where I'm at now,

Speaker:

where I can go ahead,

Speaker:

and I can travel

Speaker:

and attend events and do community sponsored things.

Speaker:

There are some challenges that remain, obviously,

Speaker:

some things that I'll never be able to do.

Speaker:

I'll never be able to drive, for example, given my vision,

Speaker:

but getting from point A to point B

Speaker:

isn't necessarily a challenge anymore

Speaker:

as long as I do it with safety in mind,

Speaker:

I can't be going out

Speaker:

and traveling at like nine p.m. at night

Speaker:

because of my vision,

Speaker:

but everything else we've developed as a society

Speaker:

to a point where I can do a lot of the things

Speaker:

that I need to now

Speaker:

because of the level of technology

Speaker:

and access we have now

Speaker:

that just really wouldn't be possible

Speaker:

in the early 90's when I was growing up.

Speaker:

- Well, I wanna come back

Speaker:

and dig into how we work to improve our digital products

Speaker:

and services with respect to those physical challenges.

Speaker:

But maybe for the next piece

Speaker:

you could talk a little bit about

Speaker:

how you started to become interested in accessibility

Speaker:

as a professional practice.

Speaker:

When did you start thinking about it as something

Speaker:

that you might want to commit more of

Speaker:

your regular work life to?

Speaker:

- So for me, one of the things that,

Speaker:

one of the very first projects that I actually took on

Speaker:

before my current job is

Speaker:

I was working for a nonprofit called

Speaker:

The San Diego Futures Foundation,

Speaker:

and they doing a training program

Speaker:

specifically for disabled youth.

Speaker:

And it's something that I had never actually considered

Speaker:

just being of a disabled background myself.

Speaker:

What are the challenges that people with disabilities

Speaker:

have with gaining employment?

Speaker:

So one of the things that I had to do from that perspective

Speaker:

is how do we make the hiring process

Speaker:

or the interview process more accessible to these youth?

Speaker:

How do we make the curriculum

Speaker:

that they're gonna be going through,

Speaker:

and the interview process more accessible to them?

Speaker:

And it's something that really got me into looking at

Speaker:

these are the things that we have to ask.

Speaker:

What accommodations do they need?

Speaker:

How can we make it easier for them

Speaker:

to be able to integrate into the workforce?

Speaker:

And it's something that at the time

Speaker:

I never really expected I'd be doing later on,

Speaker:

as I got older,

Speaker:

and developed more into a consultant,

Speaker:

because the lessons I learned there

Speaker:

really branched out and helped me look at it

Speaker:

from a wider perspective of this,

Speaker:

how it affects this particular field,

Speaker:

but what about other products and services?

Speaker:

How does it affect kiosks, for example?

Speaker:

How does it affect people that are designing buildings?

Speaker:

Do they design things that are wide enough

Speaker:

for a wheelchair to fit through?

Speaker:

Or do they not really think of that

Speaker:

from an accessible standpoint,

Speaker:

because they only think about a regular person

Speaker:

when they're designing these living quarters?

Speaker:

- Well, one of the reasons

Speaker:

that I've been doing these interviews

Speaker:

is to help people who are new

Speaker:

to learning about accessibility realize that

Speaker:

we all have different journeys that take us

Speaker:

into specializing in that.

Speaker:

Was there a time when you realized that

Speaker:

there are actually people working in accessibility,

Speaker:

where it was their regular full-time job

Speaker:

to be trying to improve things?

Speaker:

- For me, one of the first times

Speaker:

I actually learned about that

Speaker:

was actually at the Blink UX concert, conference,

Speaker:

that I went to, what was it, two years ago?

Speaker:

Basically, because it was something that

Speaker:

I had never been to a conference like that before.

Speaker:

I've been to other conferences for other things,

Speaker:

but never for one that was specifically geared

Speaker:

towards accessibility,

Speaker:

and just creating that awareness of it.

Speaker:

And it was the first time

Speaker:

where I'd been in a location

Speaker:

surrounded by other people

Speaker:

with similar interests where it's like

Speaker:

hey, we're all here talking about the same thing,

Speaker:

we're covering different aspects of it,

Speaker:

and we just wanna share ideas

Speaker:

and share resources on how to make products

Speaker:

across a wide variety of areas

Speaker:

more inclusive in their design,

Speaker:

and we're doing that by including people

Speaker:

who are subject matter experts

Speaker:

because they are familiar with accessibility,

Speaker:

whether it's from a lived perspective like my own,

Speaker:

or whether it's because they learned about accessibility

Speaker:

and now they are doing it professionally,

Speaker:

and they are really, really interested in doing it

Speaker:

not just because it looks good,

Speaker:

but because it creates a more inclusive product

Speaker:

that everyone can access.

Speaker:

- Well, your lived experience

Speaker:

is certainly something that is valuable

Speaker:

as we look to designing new products and services.

Speaker:

Maybe let's dig into the specific physical challenges,

Speaker:

and kind of go one by one,

Speaker:

and you could talk about

Speaker:

what issues that you've encountered in your own life,

Speaker:

and then what types of things

Speaker:

you carry over into your analysis.

Speaker:

And so one of those would be your visual impairment.

Speaker:

So, kind of what's your lived experience for that,

Speaker:

and how do you approach it

Speaker:

when you're helping out as a consultant?

Speaker:

- So for me, with my visual impairment,

Speaker:

my thing basically is I am extremely nearsighted.

Speaker:

It also just limits my ability to be able to see things.

Speaker:

So for me, anything that I do,

Speaker:

any document that I have to read

Speaker:

has to either have the ability to be zoomed in

Speaker:

so I can read it bigger,

Speaker:

or I have to have the ability to just change the font

Speaker:

so I can read it without straining myself.

Speaker:

So the first thing that I look at

Speaker:

when I'm looking at a product,

Speaker:

it doesn't really matter if it's software

Speaker:

or a game or anything like that,

Speaker:

anything that has basically written dialogue is for me,

Speaker:

font size.

Speaker:

Is the font size something that I can change

Speaker:

or that I can look at?

Speaker:

The second aspect of it is

Speaker:

does it have a good color contrast?

Speaker:

Am I able to read it properly,

Speaker:

or do I have to take great pains,

Speaker:

like copying it into something else

Speaker:

to be able to legibly read it

Speaker:

because the background and the font

Speaker:

really just don't match,

Speaker:

and I have to strain my vision

Speaker:

to be able to read it.

Speaker:

Anything like that is just a big challenge for me.

Speaker:

Virtually, nowadays, most locations,

Speaker:

or most avenues have really good color contrast.

Speaker:

You do run into the one off product that

Speaker:

may have the terrible color contrast

Speaker:

that just needs improvement,

Speaker:

but most of the time I've seen,

Speaker:

at least the color contrast is good.

Speaker:

The main thing that I usually have to worry about

Speaker:

is the really small font

Speaker:

that they decided to implement,

Speaker:

or when they try to be fancy,

Speaker:

like oh we're gonna use this cursive font

Speaker:

that most people can't read anymore,

Speaker:

'cause they don't teach it,

Speaker:

that's very difficult for people like me to be able to read

Speaker:

because not only in some cases

Speaker:

have you just forgotten it,

Speaker:

in most cases it's just so small

Speaker:

that even if you tried to actually

Speaker:

increase the font size it really wouldn't help.

Speaker:

- Well, one of the things that we do

Speaker:

as accessibility professionals is try to

Speaker:

make our team members understand that there,

Speaker:

there are so many assistive devices that are out there

Speaker:

that can help physical challenges,

Speaker:

but it requires that,

Speaker:

that you're not doing things that in the,

Speaker:

in the software that prevents you

Speaker:

from being able to make the necessary adjustments

Speaker:

with your assistive devices.

Speaker:

- Yep.

Speaker:

No that's,

Speaker:

and that's always something that

Speaker:

it goes back to being able to design things in a way

Speaker:

where it's open for other people.

Speaker:

One thing that I've noticed

Speaker:

is just the fact that in certain cases, basically,

Speaker:

just that lack of knowledge

Speaker:

can inadvertently create barriers,

Speaker:

but the willingness to learn

Speaker:

how to design things better

Speaker:

is always gonna be an asset,

Speaker:

because then you understand,

Speaker:

okay, instead of implementing

Speaker:

this nice looking cursive font,

Speaker:

instead I'll do something else

Speaker:

that's more easy to read for everyone else.

Speaker:

It might not look as fancy,

Speaker:

but ultimately if it improves the people's ability

Speaker:

to be able to use it and read it,

Speaker:

that should be the end goal,

Speaker:

as opposed to let's make this look all nice and fancy

Speaker:

even if some people are not able to read it.

Speaker:

- And another physical challenge is mobility.

Speaker:

So maybe talk a little bit about your experience with that,

Speaker:

with digital products

Speaker:

and how you comment on that as a consultant.

Speaker:

- So, for me, the main mobility aspect that I have

Speaker:

is mainly just essentially motor skills.

Speaker:

When I was growing up,

Speaker:

I did have significantly more,

Speaker:

but now it's limited to motor skills.

Speaker:

So if I'm going ahead

Speaker:

and I'm a KIOS for example,

Speaker:

or a machine, one of those regular ATMs,

Speaker:

or just a regular machine,

Speaker:

the main thing for me has always been an issue

Speaker:

of not requiring you to do rapid movements

Speaker:

essentially right away,

Speaker:

because for me it takes time for me

Speaker:

to be able to grab something

Speaker:

and orient things a certain way.

Speaker:

Video games are basically a good example,

Speaker:

where they have certain actions you have to take,

Speaker:

and you have to do them very, very rapidly.

Speaker:

For me, those are very difficult to do,

Speaker:

just because the fact that it takes me awhile

Speaker:

to be able to do things using a controller

Speaker:

or a handheld or anything like that.

Speaker:

So really rapid responses are something where

Speaker:

it's just exceedingly difficult to perform,

Speaker:

because of how the product was designed,

Speaker:

where they're asking you to do a specific move set

Speaker:

in a very rapid fire method.

Speaker:

And it's, for me it's just creates a toll on me.

Speaker:

- And then that kind of brings us

Speaker:

to the third one I wanted to talk about,

Speaker:

which is cognitive challenges,

Speaker:

which for me is the area of accessibility

Speaker:

where there's been the least amount of improvement overall.

Speaker:

I think we pay a lot of attention to sight, mobility,

Speaker:

and sound with closed captions,

Speaker:

but with cognitive challenges

Speaker:

I think that's an area that just a lot of organizations,

Speaker:

even if they're involved in accessibility,

Speaker:

aren't really sure how to, how to approach it.

Speaker:

So maybe talk a little bit about

Speaker:

your experiences in that area,

Speaker:

and the challenges you encounter.

Speaker:

- So for, me, one of the main challenges

Speaker:

that I've always seen

Speaker:

is that as a society as a whole

Speaker:

we always wanna be able to see that we're smart, right?

Speaker:

When we're designing products and service,

Speaker:

we wanna be able to see

Speaker:

that we are very smart,

Speaker:

and there's nothing inherently wrong with that.

Speaker:

The main challenge when designing product

Speaker:

or services though,

Speaker:

specifically with cognitive challenges in mind,

Speaker:

is the fact that it goes over so many heads

Speaker:

that designing simple is best.

Speaker:

Designing things in a way

Speaker:

where you're describing things one step at a time,

Speaker:

without using any excessive words,

Speaker:

or terms that regular people who,

Speaker:

or people who, for example,

Speaker:

may not have gone to college are not gonna understand,

Speaker:

is something that it's a simple concept,

Speaker:

but it's not really implemented that often.

Speaker:

And it's something that I've always seen,

Speaker:

'cause people like myself who have cognitive challenges,

Speaker:

and it's unusual because I work in tech,

Speaker:

but it's because I have cognitive challenges

Speaker:

that even working in tech

Speaker:

I still design

Speaker:

okay, we're gonna do this one step at a time.

Speaker:

First we're gonna do this,

Speaker:

and then this next step,

Speaker:

and then this third step

Speaker:

to finish up the project or whatever activity we're doing.

Speaker:

And it's something that,

Speaker:

what I've seen using certain products

Speaker:

or services or websites, it's not done that way.

Speaker:

They have an expectation where people

Speaker:

are automatically gonna understand a certain set

Speaker:

of complicated instructions without being told

Speaker:

exactly what to do for step one

Speaker:

or for step two or for step three.

Speaker:

And the challenge with that is

Speaker:

not only is it ignoring the fact that

Speaker:

not everyone using that same product

Speaker:

or service is gonna be at the same educational level,

Speaker:

it's ignoring the fact that not everyone

Speaker:

is gonna be at the same cognitive level as well.

Speaker:

There are some people like myself would,

Speaker:

can still be very high functioning,

Speaker:

but we still need some sort of breakdown

Speaker:

in terms of the steps to do a certain thing.

Speaker:

Like a good example that I've always referenced basically

Speaker:

is those Ikea catalogs,

Speaker:

when you have to actually build something.

Speaker:

All it is is just pictures.

Speaker:

That doesn't tell me what I'm doing.

Speaker:

Using that one as a good example,

Speaker:

just looking at a reference point.

Speaker:

Me being visually impaired,

Speaker:

and just looking at this

Speaker:

and not having any actual instructions,

Speaker:

it is like the most challenging thing to do,

Speaker:

because I'm not being told specifically what to do

Speaker:

in step by step instruction.

Speaker:

- And we're working on an article together related to this,

Speaker:

and one of the things that you brought out in that

Speaker:

is, for example, if you are filling out a form

Speaker:

or working through a procedure

Speaker:

is that your short term memory,

Speaker:

it doesn't necessarily carry over too long so that

Speaker:

even within individual steps

Speaker:

it's useful for you to have,

Speaker:

continue to have detail about what to do,

Speaker:

and then what the next step is.

Speaker:

- Exactly.

Speaker:

Using just some forms that I've seen on the internet,

Speaker:

for example, they'll have like, oh,

Speaker:

please put in this information,

Speaker:

and then at the bottom,

Speaker:

when you're done with the information,

Speaker:

it'll say this information will be used for this or that.

Speaker:

And, for me, with my brain thinking

Speaker:

is if you tell me why I need to put in this information

Speaker:

at the very beginning,

Speaker:

before I get to that information,

Speaker:

as opposed to at the very end,

Speaker:

because then if I'm forgetting why I'm putting it,

Speaker:

I can just reference it at the very top,

Speaker:

oh, this is why I'm doing it,

Speaker:

and then just fill it out.

Speaker:

And if I need to it's at the very top of the form,

Speaker:

and it flows just a lot better.

Speaker:

Whereas if the information's at the bottom,

Speaker:

I would've forgotten why I'm putting it in.

Speaker:

Oh, why is my name up here?

Speaker:

I don't remember anymore,

Speaker:

'cause I'm not being told

Speaker:

exactly why I need to put it in in some cases.

Speaker:

- Yeah.

Speaker:

And in the article we get into hit lines that disappear

Speaker:

and popups that may not persist.

Speaker:

One of the other areas that you brought up

Speaker:

was when, I think you referred to it as

Speaker:

just too many things going on

Speaker:

or a really busy screen,

Speaker:

and that focus can be an issue.

Speaker:

- Yep, definitely.

Speaker:

'Cause for me, nowadays it's not as bad

Speaker:

as when I was younger,

Speaker:

but I still suffer somewhat from my ADHD challenges

Speaker:

where it's like

Speaker:

if I'm reading an article where if there's too much

Speaker:

I kind of have to break it down into sections,

Speaker:

but if I see an ad or something,

Speaker:

or a banner just pops up,

Speaker:

my intention is immediately diverted to that.

Speaker:

And I'll forget where I was.

Speaker:

What was I reading?

Speaker:

What column was I on?

Speaker:

What was I trying to do?

Speaker:

Because it just diverts so much from what I was doing,

Speaker:

and it just creates a challenge

Speaker:

in being able to finish whatever article

Speaker:

or activity I was trying to do.

Speaker:

- Well, I think everyone

Speaker:

will find this information very helpful,

Speaker:

and I think our article have a lot of good info as well.

Speaker:

For you, just looking ahead,

Speaker:

what types of things are you working on?

Speaker:

What are you looking forward to

Speaker:

in the next part of your career?

Speaker:

- So for right now I'm still freelancing basically.

Speaker:

I am currently gonna be in the process of mentoring

Speaker:

some people on accessibility with a new volunteer group

Speaker:

that just opened up.

Speaker:

In the long term I do plan on

Speaker:

being able to land an official accessibility job

Speaker:

down the line,

Speaker:

just because that is something that for me

Speaker:

is always near dear to my heart.

Speaker:

It's not something where it would just be a job,

Speaker:

but something where I can help make products more accessible

Speaker:

for a wide variety of people

Speaker:

would be just the end goal for me long term.

Speaker:

- All right, well great.

Speaker:

Ricardo, it's been great talking with you,

Speaker:

thank you for sharing your ideas.

Speaker:

It's also been good to work with you,

Speaker:

and I look forward to doing that some more,

Speaker:

and I hope we can get together at some point

Speaker:

at a physical event again in the future.

Speaker:

- Yeah, definitely.

Speaker:

It's always happy to.

Speaker:

I was hopeful to lend a hand,

Speaker:

so we'll have to see when that is.

Speaker:

- All right, thanks a lot.

About the Podcast

Show artwork for Digital Accessibility
Digital Accessibility
The People Behind the Progress

About your host

Profile picture for Joe Welinske

Joe Welinske

Serving as Accessibility Director at Blink is Joe's main activity. Blink is devoted to helping ensure that digital products and services can be used by everyone. As Director, Joe is responsible for helping Blink's practitioners to build accessibility into everything they do. He also evangelizes the need for accessibility with Blink's clients and partners.
Joe is a co-organizer of the Seattle Inclusive Design and Accessibility meetup group and he serves as the Secretary of the King County Metro Paratransit Advisory Committee.